To make it, I just got a big jar and created the "Creepy Conversations" label for the front. Inside were typed questions on little sheets of paper. The questions ranged from silly, to morbid, to serious. To play the game, I picked questions from the jar and read them aloud. Then we went around the room taking turns answering. I can't remember all of the questions, but some of them were:
"When were you most scared? What happened?"
"If you could have one superpower, what would it be and why?"
"Do you believe in ghosts or the afterlife?"
"Have you, or someone who know, ever seen a ghost? If so, tell us the story."
"What was your favorite Halloween costume as a kid?"
"Would you rather have spiders crawling all over you, or mice?"
"What is your biggest fear in life?"
"Would you rather spend the night alone in a morgue or a cemetery?"
"Do you like scary movies? If so, what's your favorite?"
" A la horror movie death scenes . . . what would be your least favorite way to die?"
"Would you rather be attacked with an ax or a chainsaw?"
"Would you rather have no fingers or no teeth?"
"What's your favorite Halloween candy?"
As I said, some questions were kind of silly but others were really morbid or serious. Anyway, it was a fun party game. And a good one if you're worried about lulls in conversation.
I didn't do any other games, but did have a costume contest with prizes. I made this little sign and typed-up ballots . . .